Chapter 7 - A Grave Without a Name

The address led to a narrow house on a quiet street in Albany. Its owner, retired medical examiner Dr. Lionel Shaw, met them wearing slippers and holding an old lab notebook like a shield.

“I should have come forward years ago,” Shaw said, before they crossed the threshold.

Sixteen years earlier, he had been asked to sign an amended death certificate for a young man pulled from the Hudson. The remains were too damaged for visual identification. Arthur supplied dental records through a private dentist. Shaw had questioned the mismatch, then received a call from a superior who warned that his career would end if he delayed the funeral.

“Was it Caleb?” Evelyn asked.

“I don't know,” Shaw said. “And that's what I should have written.”

He showed them the original chart. Two teeth listed in the victim's mouth had been removed from Caleb during childhood. The discrepancy was small enough to hide, serious enough to unravel the identification.

“Why keep this?”

“Because cowardice doesn't disappear when you retire.”

Dana photographed the record with his permission and arranged a formal statement. Evelyn barely heard them. Her brother might be alive, but Hannah's warning suggested the man using his name was dangerous.

On the way out, Shaw caught her arm. “A woman came to see me last winter. Dark hair, nurse's coat. She asked the same questions.”

“Hannah died three years ago.”

“This was a different woman. She introduced herself as Mara Mercer.”

Evelyn froze. Mara was Caleb's wife, presumed to have left the state after his death. Evelyn had sent Christmas cards to a forwarded address for five years without a reply.

Dana searched the name. Mara owned a small pharmacy in Newburgh, but it had closed suddenly six months earlier.

At Noah's apartment that night, Evelyn found a package waiting at the front desk. There was no return address. Inside was Caleb's childhood compass, the one she had given him when they were kids, and a photograph of a boy standing outside a run-down brick building.

Across the photograph someone had written: HIS SON DESERVES THE TRUTH.

May you like

Billionaire’s Wife Kicked a Waitress in Front of 300 Elites—One Slap Exp...

The billionaire’s wife tried to kick a waitress in the face in front of 300 wealthy guests. But seconds later, she whispered three...

My Mother Grabbed My Wife by the Hair Over Cold Soup—But What My Father...

My mother grabbed my wife by the hair over a bowl of cold soup. And the most shameful part? For one terrible second, I almost defe...

My Parents Kicked My 6-Year-Old Daughter and Me Out on Christmas—Then I...

My mother kicked my six-year-old daughter out of Christmas dinner, never realizing I was the only reason she still had a house to...

Evelyn turned it over.

On the back was the same address from Hannah's email.